Prep, Ivy, varsity. Whatever you want to call it, it’s rooted in sophistication without effort. Pastel button downs, slacks, maybe a sport jacket, and on the feet? Loafers or boat shoes; take your pick, just NOT Crocs.

Or so we thought. It turns out that the Crocs Classic Islander might have more prep pedigree than you imagined.

Look, we’re joking. Obviously styling a clean preppy outfit with a pair of Crocs is analogous, but therein lies the beauty of it. It’s so wrong that it’s kinda right…

Most of contemporary luxury fashion is built on the premise that opposition is the most fruitful area for creativity. Hell, Demna’s built an entire career off of it. It’s within the tension between opposing forces that art finds some of its most effective expressions.

The Crocs Classic Islander starts from the signature rubber clog shape but features an additional layer around the collar complete with the 180-degree lacing system that defines boat shoes.

And sure, a pair of leather boat shoes will always feel more sophisticated than a rubber clog, but for anyone who’s actually taking these out on the water (none of you, we know) the perforated rubber build of the Crocs Classic Islander is a clear winner.

So while there’s definitely something humorous about the Classic Islander, there’s also something foundationally interesting about them from a style perspective. It’s up to you how to play that.

Highsnobiety has affiliate marketing partnerships, which means we may receive a commission from your purchase. Want to shop the products our editors actually love? Visit HS Shopping for recs on all things fashion, footwear, and beauty.